Mary’s Bagel Café

I enjoyed their Wall Street Egg Tomato sandwich and a med latte with just milk + two shots of flavor. Delicious! Coffee is fresh and smooth, croissant was hot, fluffy and enjoyable (the eggs were cooked perfectly too, not rubbery or fake)
The atmosphere is nice, even when it’s busy it’s not too loud, and they never appeared slow.
5 Stars because they were kind and worth coming back too!

Only surprise was the coffee size + price, but it was worth it and satisfied.

First time here and this cafe is beautiful. The menu is pretty fast with several bagel sandwich combinations listed and several bagels to choose from. We ordered an everything bagel with bacon egg and cheese (the Bronx Bacon Egg) $7.49 and a plain bagel with egg and cheese (Grand Central) $5.99, an iced coffee $3.99 and an iced latte $3.89. The drinks are really good, the bagels are lovely. The staff is warm and friendly. There is plenty of parking. This seems like a popular cafe and we can see why. Mary’s is a place we will return to and recommend.

I stopped in this morning (Monday 1/30) around 10am. There was a very short line and my order was taken quickly. I ordered a Staten Island Ham, I believe — ham, egg, cheese — on a pumpernickel bagel. From order to receipt of sandwich was maybe 5 minutes. I’m originally from NJ and have been longing for good bagels for 11 years! Could drive to South Lakeland, but that’s no fun to do regularly. Anyway…my sandwich was DELICIOUS!! I’m so happy to have somewhere closer to go when I want a nice bagel. Employees were super friendly, too. If you tried this place and had an issue, try them again before bashing them. Every place has some kinks to work out when they’re new! I’ll definitely be back!

I’ve visited during their grand opening, Denise and her staff are wonderful. The line was out the door and it was worth the wait. I ordered the radio city breakfast sandwich on a onion bagel. It’s not often I find a corn beef breakfast sandwich so I was delighted they had it on their menu. Thank you for a wonderful breakfast Mary’s bagel Café.