Holly Hill Inn

We went for our Anniversary and we couldn’t have had a more perfect dinner!!! The food was unreal good, service was high class!! Thank you so much!!!

Fantastic dinning experience as we celebrated our anniversary. The set menu was perfect. Excellent service, food and drink. We thoroughly enjoyed the entire evening. Thanks to Connor for taking care of us.

An absolute gem. Superb service and great food and drink. We're so lucky to have this place. Please note that it's pricey and worth it.

Amazing dining experience! All of our selections for the four course dinner and wine pairing were fantastic. Above the food and service we also really enjoyed the historic home and learning the history of the former owners and uses of the property. Highly recommend!

It took me almost 36 years, but I finally made it to Holly Hill Inn, which in itself is a shame since they have BRUNCH! We enjoyed a fantastic 4-course dinner on the eve of the my fiancé’s parents 55th wedding anniversary.

🍽 Amuse Bouche: Cherry tomato tart (I could have eaten an ACTUAL pie-sized version of this perfection)
🍝 House pasta with pistachio pesto
🍗 Joe’s duck breast, fresh corn polenta, plum sauce, roasted grapes
🍑 Peach-blackberry galette, buttermilk ice cream, bourbon caramel
🍹 Bourbon blackberry bramble

(Plus his red snapper and dark chocolate mousse cake)

Two critical pieces of feedback:

1) The atmosphere they’re going for is upscale, small, and ideally intimate, but it cannot be so when one can hear the conversations at every other table (and know that they can hear yours). As of that weren’t bad enough, every door in the place is open and you can hear dishes clanging and glasses clinking. Something could be done to improve the acoustics, regardless of the age of the structure.

2) While delicious, the means do not justify the ends when it comes to the four-course meal. $55 is quite a stretch for the portions we received, namely the third (main) course, and I wasn’t the only one who looked quizzically at my plate when it arrived. So keep that in mind.

The service was exceptional from a professionalism standpoint, but all businesses are short-staffed right now and - understandably - service is slow and you might wait 20 minutes for someone to stop long enough to notice every drink at your table is empty. That’s ok. That said, many of the wine bottles are very reasonably priced, so order a bottle and forego the wait!