Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant

I typically only get takeout, but I've never been disappointed with a pie. Staff has always been kind, service has always been quick, and I have always finished my food feeling satisfied.

Highly recommend Brothers pizza. This is our favorite local pizzeria. My family has been coming here for years, and never had anything but a great meal. The dining area is always very clean, and Shannon at the counter is always very pleasant to deal with.

First time getting food from here and it was great! Very fresh. I love how they just put Mozzarella sticks in a brown paper bag, very crisp and tasty!

Moved to Wantage, NJ in November 21'. Brother's Pizza was the first food my family and friends had after a long day of moving. The lady on the phone was pleasant and sympathetic to our transient condition offering us plates, napkins, utensils, and cups. They even remembered us on the next ordered and asked if we were settling in okay, a nice touch.

We've ordered here several times and regardless of the day of the week our order is always correct, delivered with a smile, and arrives within a reasonable amount of time. Our very first order came with a welcome note that was handwritten welcoming us to the neighborhood, also a very nice touch.

I'm big on loyalty but have given a couple other local pizza shops a go...hands down, sticking with Brother's for the timing, quality, and accuracy.