Bagel Boss Hicksville

Finally had a decent bagel. Maybe not as good as H & H or any of the old time NYC bagel places ( I think the water on Long Island is not as good as the water in the city), but definitely a huge improvement over anything that we get back at home.
A bit of advice. Order in advance. The lines on Sunday morning, when of course you want them fresh, are quite long.

These bagels are the best. Our family gets them every time we are in town. I'm checking a bag just so I can bring 2 dozen back to Colorado with me 😂 Can't get bagels like this out West!

Love this place. Great bagels. 24 hours is amazing. I always stop to bring some to family when going out of town.

Great neighborhood bagel place.

True Long Island bagels - after you eat one of these deli quality bagels the packaged ones from the supermarkets, grocery stores, or Dunkin Donuts taste like bread.

Large interior, great coffee options, lots of bagel options, lots of deli cold salad options.

Layout is slightly chaotic - the line forms in the middle, but orders are taken to the right, and the deli stuff is to the left.

Best feature - the store never closes. I haven’t tested the truth in their words, but you should be able to head there in the middle of the night and still get your deli cravings met.

Also love their pies in the winter!

Unfortunately they have followed the recent trend to ding credit card / Apple Pay customers with a surcharge, instead of going the other way to give the cash customers a discount.