Tortuga Sandwich Shop

The hype is real! Finally stopped here having driven by a 100 times. Actually drove past again, then turned around. Glad I did. Ordered the Gustavo and it was very delicious, and cleverly wrapped to make eating it easier. The place was clean, cool music and relatively fast service. The side of coleslaw was nice too. Try it out!!!

Wonderful shop in Sanborn. Got the chili to with chips. Very tasty sandwich. My only complaint was there was a little fat on the edge of the ribeye that I thought should have been trimmed off. Also got a slice of the cake to take home. OMG it is soooo good. Overall highly recommend.

Small, local and friendly vibes. Chill, low-key decor and devastatingly good food. Had the Gustavo chicken sandwich and I fear that any chicken sandwich I have from now on will pale in comparison with that. Fast service and decent prices. Will definitely be going back.

The other reviews are spot on. You pull up and you're in a not-pretty looking area, the front of the store looks eh. You're thinking... this place looks rough. You go in and still not super impressed by the interior. You order a sandwich and are thinking all these other reviews led you astray.... Then you get the sandwich, start eating and can't stop. They make an outstanding product. Do not judge them by their exterior, they whip up some delicious food. I highly recommend if you're in the area to stop by and give them a try. I will definitely be returning! Easily best sandwich in the Buffalo area!

Great experience, friendly staff, quick service. Awesome menu, we got the pepe and Gustavo sandwiches with an order of the Madrid potatoes. Will definitely come here again to try more of the menu!