Carroll's Jewelers

This is a place you want to do business. Everyone behind the counter is NICE. They remember you! In the current digital age, it's refreshing to find a traditional, family owned establishment to buy and maintain your valuables and get treated like a person rather than a number. Thanks for everything!

Carrol’s was a great place to get an engagement ring! They had a great selection and I could tell right away I was in good hands in terms of quality and knowledge. Kate helped me out and saved the day when my selection needed some tweaking. They were awesome and it allowed for the perfect engagement, definitely will be a return customer and recommend to anyone who isn’t a jewelry wizard but wants a great product at a fair price.

I have worked with Suzanne on multiple occasions. She has helped me find/create jewelry that exceeds my expectations. Her guidance, professionalism, and overall attention to detail throughout the process made things very easy. I highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy any jewelry. Very happy with the end result, and my girlfriend (now fiancé) was too!

Carroll’s is where my now-husband found my engagement ring back in 2021 and they have been amazing with customer service, timing, and pricing for the past two years. We went back to them for our wedding bands. My wedding band was easy to find, it was the complimentary band made by Gabriel & Co. for my engagement ring. But, for my husband, he saw a few examples in the case but also saw some options online that Kate brought up on their tablet. Not knowing for certain which band he was leaning towards, Kate and the team were able to bring in a few additional options so he could see them in-person before making the final choice.
For the day of the wedding, we saw a Gabriel & Co. delicate necklace in their catalog, so Kate was also able to bring in the exact necklace we were eying and I tried it on a few weeks later. My experience with Kate and Gabriel & Co. has been very easy for new pieces and we had quite a few blue Carroll’s Jewelers boxes at the wedding! Thank you Kate and the rest of the team!

Guys - Pay Joel at Carroll's a visit before spending money on jewelry anywhere else. I purchased an engagement ring for my (now) wife from Carroll's and it was the best decision I've ever made. We live in Manhattan and shopped around the city for awhile but Carroll's was able to deliver exactly what we wanted for a much more reasonable price. In short, my wife wanted a very specific setting that Joel went FAR out of his way to make happen for us. We were so happy with how the engagement ring turned out that we went back to Joel for our wedding bands, my wife's being a custom eternity band with small emerald stones that Joel hand-selected just for us. Thank you, Joel!