Bella's Pizzeria

Latest update x 2. Two weeks since the last update. Again consistency is spot on. There is no other shop like it. Of course we enjoyed our food. I'm getting kinda sick of Bella's honestly. I've had it so many times. But taking a break from Bella's only means disappointment :(. Our family loves your Bella's. I think you should franchise. We are blessed to have you in our town.

Latest update. I've been here a dozen of times since my last review. I really don't want to go anywhere else. The consistency is key for me. It's the same each time!

Update: Consistency was spot on for our last visit. They use a different hoagie roll than all the other shops around Pittsburgh. I dont know if they make it themselves, but it certainly is several notches above what the others sell. For $16 I swear that sub is 2' long. It sure seems longer than the 18" they advertise. Their sub roll is also wider than most by some, or by much vs subway for example.

Imagine foxes done better, it has that texture. When I first tried Bella's I disliked the pizza. Sweet and limp. We tried again today and their dough reminds me of an upscale foxes. Not crispy but not soggy, chewy a bit with a nice enough crisp. Trust me Im not a huge foxes pizza and dont want people thinking this pizza is like foxes, but you'll know what I mean when you try Bella's. There's a texture that foxes has when it's done right that is what made it so popular. Bella's dough is good, really good. It has a bit of that texture with a slight crunch and a nice chew. Sauce tastes good, nicely balanced. It does not taste like it came from a can, it tastes fresh. Cheese on top of pepperoni. We took one bite and were like eh ok...then second bite hmm...third bite yes, this is the way. This is a good pie. Not overly anything, well balanced. Add salt if you want to, but it's not overly salty.
We also got a sub. Monster sized for 15 or so dollars but enough to feed four people for lunch, or 2 for a large dinner with a small piece left over. It was good, not overly toasted and enough cold ingredients although I wish they had some more lettuce, but I want more lettuce all the time that's just me. Nice beefy pieces of tomato, red. The sub roll was high quality. Wife really liked her sub, I can tell she is hooked. She won't want to go anywhere else for subs...ever, I know this to be true.
I see why so many people rate this place highly. Consistency is important to me so let's see how it is order over order.
After special I gotta say this is the most bang for the buck pizza shop in the rostraver/BV area.

Most pizza places in the area are just average but not bellas. I've never had something I didn't like from here and have been happy with my order every single time. They make great specialty pizzas, and every employee I've spoken to is very polite

As a local small business we do our best to support others like us. Their coupon on the back of my West Newton Giant Eagle receipt caught my eye. I was a bachelor this weekend and decided to try something besides the usual Fox's ... very glad I did. Everybody's taste is different but I was happy with ordering, timely pickup and the pie was great, no skimpy peperoni. We play cards every few weeks and you will get our next order!