Jamestown Pie Company

• Alexandra Smith
  
  
  (April 12, 2023, 6:15 pm)

  The savory seafood pot pie was so good! The seafood is cooked perfectly, mounded up high inside a delicious pie shell and the sauce it's in is delicious!
  
  Also got 2 sweet pies. Unfortunately, they don't have very many of their pies available in slices so we ended up with the coconut custard (very good) and the chocolate peanut (wanted the chocolate pecan but they only had that as a whole pie). The chocolate peanut didn't really have any chocolate and the peanuts would have been better if they were chopped. They were whole and kind of tough to chew.
  
  Overall, would definitely go back for the savory pie and would try other sweet pies.

• Geoff Wilson
  
  
  (October 5, 2022, 12:01 am)

  Whether you're looking for a sweet treat for the whole family or a sneaky little slice for yourself, this pie shop has so many varieties you cannot not find something you'd like - at least in the dessert variety. There's some basic outdoor seating and nothing inside besides the counter and a little deli cabinet of takeaway pies ready to be gobbled down. We got plastic forks for ours to eat in the car ;)

• Joshua Myers
  
  
  (June 16, 2022, 11:17 pm)

  An absolutely amazing place.
  
  When you travel, you always look for that "just off the beaten-path place where you wouldn't expect to find amazing food, but you do" kind of restaurant.
  
  This is that place. The pizza was delicious - the dough was perfectly crisp and the crust was gone before I even had the chance to think about not eating it. The desserts were also delicious (I had one heck of a baklava), the prices are incredibly fair, and yet, the best part was actually the people who own this restaurant. Their friendly smiles were truly the highlight of my vacation - so much so that I felt compelled to commemorate our second visit with a group photo.
  
  When you go, you're part of the family. The food is made with love. It sounds cliché, but it tastes great.

• Peter Roman
  
  
  (May 4, 2022, 5:04 pm)

  So wife and I were on our way to Williamsburg off the Jamestown Ferry and spotted this place. Definitely peaked my interest. After playing pack mule for my wife carrying around all the bags and whatnot from her shopping day, I worked up an appetite. She suggested we stop at "that little place we saw off the ferry". Let's go
  
  Jamestown Pie Company is a small unassuming place, nothing overly exciting to look at but in my experience you never judge a book by it's cover.
  And with this place in particular, don't. You'll miss out on something truly amazing.
  
  Service was absolutely perfect. The gentleman was very friendly, knowledgeable and an absolute pleasure to talk with.
  
  Our order today was an 18 inch pizza with pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatball, bacon and red onions, and a slice of the blueberry peach pie (couldn't resist)
  The pizza was great. The crust was cooked perfectly, the toppings were deliciously hot and picture perfect. I mean look at the pic. (My wife snagged a slice before I could take it) But isn't that a good looking pizza? It was really hot so it was all hands on deck, two hands and fold. OMG what a flavor!! Everything balanced out so nicely. Just the right amount of crust, toppings and melty cheese. Not greasy or salty from the sausage, nothing over powered anything so the flavors were all represented. Very well done
  
  Now the blueberry peach pie was my thing as my wife is not fond of fruit pies. So this one was all mine. 1 bite and I was hooked. Not overtly sweet, definitely fresh ingredients, (no canned filling here) and the buttery, flakey, to die for crust was scrumptious to say the least. This was a slice of pie I could pick up with my hand and it would stay together. I know this because I did it. When the bottom crust of a fruit pie will allow you to lift off the plate and not fall apart, oh this is going to be good. The bite was substantial. Buttery crust combined with a slight tartness of blueberry and a hint of sweet peach. Man oh man, I'm in heaven. If you're a blueberry lover like me then you'll love this pie.
  
  So to summarize, great service, great food, it was a beautiful day so outdoor seating was enjoyable (no indoor seating) and a wonderful lunch all together.
  By the way, my wife and i had 1 slice of pizza each so we brought the rest home and my son devoured the rest of the pizza. So it fed 3 people. Grading as follows:
  
  Service: A+
  Pizza: A
  Pie: A+
  Overall visit score: A
  
  Great job Jamestown Pie Company. Keep it up.
  And if you find yourself in the Williamsburg Jamestown area, you owe it to yourself to stop by. I'll be back to try the pot pies. Enjoy!!!

Jamestown Pie Company in Williamsburg, VA 23185 - (757) 229-7775

Jamestown Pie Company at 1804 Jamestown Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23185. Get Jamestown Pie Company can be contacted at (757) 229-7775. Get Jamestown Pie Company reviews, rating, hours, phone number, directions and more.

JAMESTOWN PIE COMPANY - 151 Photos & 191 Reviews - Yelp

The hubs, father in law, and I were driving through the Williamsburg area. Jamestown Pie Company caught our eye and we made an immediate unplanned stop. We all are very fond of sweets, but mostly pies such as coconut, key lime, and pecan. ... (757) 229-7775. Get Directions. 1804 Jamestown Rd Williamsburg, VA 23185. Is this your business?

ABOUT US - Buy A Pie

757-229-7775. Williamsburg, VA. ... Instagram. Menu. HOME; ABOUT US; ONLINE ORDER; FRUIT PIES; NUTTY PIES; SPECIAL PIES; GOURMET PIZZA; CONTACT; Product was added to your cart. Cart. ABOUT US. Home ABOUT US. Jamestown Pie Company. is a father and son owned and operated local business located in the historic town of Colonial, Williamsburg, ...

Jamestown Pie Company - Buy a Pie

757-229-7775. Williamsburg, VA. Facebook. Instagram. Menu. HOME; ABOUT US; ONLINE ORDER; FRUIT PIES; NUTTY PIES; SPECIAL PIES; GOURMET PIZZA; CONTACT; Product was added to your cart. Cart. JAMESTOWN PIE COMPANY Because round food is good food . World Famous Pecan Pie $ 22.99. Add to cart. Apple Pie $ 31.99. Add to cart. Pumpkin $ 18.99. Add to ...

Jamestown Pie Company - 1804 Jamestown Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23185

Check Address, Phone, Hours, Website, Reviews and other information for Jamestown Pie Company at 1804 Jamestown Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23185, USA.

Jamestown Pie Company in Williamsburg, VA 23185 - 757-229-7775

( 609 Reviews ) 1804 Jamestown Rd Williamsburg, VA 23185 757-229-7775; Claim Your Listing

Jamestown Pie Company | Williamsburg VA - Facebook

Jamestown Pie Company, Williamsburg, Virginia. 143 likes · 1 talking about this · 81 were here. We have a wide selection of Homemade Pies, Hot Pot Pies, Oven toasted Sandwichs and Pizza! Jamestown Pie Company | Williamsburg VA

Jamestown Pie Company menu - Williamsburg VA 23185 - (757 ... - Allmenus

The Surry Pizza. White sauce, jumbo lump crabmeat and prosciutto ham. The Mississippi Pizza. Marinara, shrimp, mushrooms and andouille sausage. The Jamestown Pizza. White sauce, shrimp, mushrooms and garlic. The Spicy Salami Pizza. Red sauce, genoa salami, feta and pepperoncini. The Arno Pizza.

Jamestown Pie Company - Official MapQuest

Jamestown Pie Company. ... (757) 229-7775. Claim this business (757) 229-7775. Website. More. Directions Advertisement. History. Totaly own by family ,new and better management, better and great taste guaranteeing best quality service :) Specialties. gourmet pizza pie , sandwiches,deep dish pot pie,and dessert pie's ...