PSJ Cellar

THIS PLACE IS A HIDDEN GEM! 💎
Food…incredible. I had the cheesesteak, bun was crispy yet soft, meat was flavored perfectly, juicy, and the vegetables were fresh & cooked right!

My husband had the FarmHouse Flatbread with Apples and Bacon, which I also tried and it was BOMB.

The soft drinks come in actual BIG glasses so no need to ask for 5 refills in a sitting. The bar drinks were also extremely tasty!!

Amber our waitress was super friendly and helpful! We will definitely be back when we visit again!

Went during lunch time and got our order very quick.
I ordered the goat burger and would definitely recommend! Great atmosphere, service and food.

PSJ Cellar Restaurant & Bar, 3780 Curtis Boulevard, Port Saint John, Florida, 32927-

4-Stars

If I graded on the offensive nature of my server, PSJ Cellar would get zero stars. Jean is an old restaurant hand who has seen it all in her 70-plus years. If she ever did believe in service with a smile, she is long over it. Don’t get me wrong, Jean did her job. She was just abrasive and obnoxious. I thought maybe it was just my adorable personality, but no. She spoke poorly to everyone in the restaurant. At any rate, PSJ Cellar is a clean and modern-looking establishment serving excellent offerings. I recommend it. I’m not sure why it is located on a poorly traveled road. I guess the owners deemed the concept “location is everything” a canard. But hey, it works, and I hope this review helps you find it.

My first choice was from the Burgers & Sandwiches section of the menu, the Shrimp Po’Boy, which had large fried shrimp, lettuce, and tomato, served on a toasted buttered hoagie roll, with a great drizzle of PSJ po’boy sauce. The crispy chips that came with it were nicely seasoned and appeared to be made in house.

From the Tacos section, I selected the Fish Tacos, two of them filled with fried fish, cabbage, mozzarella cheese, pico, and a chimichurri drizzle, served with corn salad. These tacos were tasty. Maybe not the best I’ve ever had but satisfying all the same.

The Big Boy says, “Don’t let Cantankerous Jean scare you away, PSJ Cellar’s fare is worth a try.”

Nice restaurant, the food was good. Our bartender was nice also. To me it felt like just an average restaurant, nothing special but they do have ok food. The atmosphere feels like it's missing something. Good place to grab a bite to eat.

The best hidden gem in the Cocoa area. When we arrived we were asked to seat ourselves. Then, over the next 15 minutes, we sat. Finally, our server arrived. She was friendly and well educated on the menu, which was used well after the paper expiration date.
Our server took our order and brought our drinks and salads. The food was very well prepared and made to order. Everything we ate was flavorful and very well made. It is also good to note that the service after the initial 15 minutes was impeccable, service was outstanding. The manager came by and asked how our meal was, and we shared our options. Afterward, I asked for a dessert menu. The manager said she would make me a dessert she was thinking about adding to the menu, a Cinnamon Crunch Ice cream Extravaganza. I promptly said yes, and she left. When she returned, she presented us with the most delicately made hand-made ice cream dessert I have ever tasted. Just the dessert would give this place a 5 star rating. It was creamy and delicate, and the cinnamon sticks were handmade, and the entire thing drizzled with caramel. What a tasty treat. Know we will be back for more.