The Fish House

This place is open later than some places which leaves it packed at the evening rolls around. Food was very tasty, but I was not a fan of my Chardonnay. Key lime pie with the meringue is award worthy.

Hands Down THE BEST FOOD IN KEY LARGO !!
Thank you to the locals that recommended.
This place was featured on Guy Fieri & Bobby Flay - and it shows
Scores :
Matecumbe with Yellow Snapper 9.1
Rice and Beans 8.3
Clam chowder 8.8
Fried Yellow Snapper 8.9
Key Lime Pie 9.3 (the best in town - the meringue to filling to graham cracker crust ratio is spot on)

Food, atmosphere, and a perfect stop along the Keys. The place stayed busy, but food was fast and REALLY good. Fun decor, and a lively feel, without being noisy. A great place to stop during our trip.

Stopped by on a Sunday for lunch. There was no wait and our server was very attentive. I love the authenticity of the restaurant inside from the food to the decor. It really reminds you of the keys. We tried the lobster bisque which was incredible and we got 2 grouper sandwiches, one fried and one Jamaican jerk style. Both were consistent and so delicious. The coleslaw and fries were also good! Overall, great experience and will definitely be back. Oh and we didn’t get any dessert but my mom swears by the key lime pie here. One of the best in the keys.

The wait was about 50 minutes on a Sunday night in late March for a party of 4. The place was hopping. Service was fast. The waiters worked together to take care of everybody. They seemed to enjoy their jobs and were really friendly. Try the oysters, fried seafood platter, and Mahi sandwich. All were amazing. But the absolute do not miss is the coconut ice cream for dessert! It is incredible- some of the best ice cream I've ever had! The peanut butter pie is good too.