Pepperoni's Pizza

Wonderful people and food!! Deb and Alan are great hosts! We went early and were lucky enough to hit a slow time, so had a chance to chat with them. Deb waited on us, (hubby worked on their electric so had already met them), our yummy appetizer was less than 5 minutes coming, best breaded mushrooms and onion rings I've had in awhile. We couldn't make up our mind so half extra pepperoni, half Sylvan feast on the pizza. It was loaded with toppings all the way to the edge with heaps of cheese. This is our new pizza go-to for sure! Thanks for a fantastic meal, see you again soon.

BEST ONION RINGS EVER (and I've had a lot of them). Owner Deb was in the kitchen when we visited and she cooked up some amazing rings. Pizza is great and the staff is friendly. We visited from the West Coast and we would definitely go back just for the amazing rings! Oh, and it was waaaaay underpriced for the amount of food we got, the service, and the tastiness!

Great pizza! Best Wings! It's a long wait, but well worth it!

I have a hard time giving out five star reviews but I think this place earned it. Unfortunately I didn't get any pictures of our pizza from Pepperonis in Rome City. We ordered 10 large pizzas for a rehearsal dinner to be ready at 5:45 on a Friday night. This place was absolutely amazing. They had all of our pizzas ready to go when we got there. We had a variety of most of their specialty pizzas and they each were incredible. Deluxe, cheeseburger, hawaiian, meat lovers Sylvan feast, cheese, taco, and a couple others. I had some of each of them and they were amazing I highly recommend this place.

Heard about this little place for at least a year & this super pizza they offer. Large assortment of pizza, subs, salads, and appetizers. Great Hoosier hospitality.
We had pepporoni/mushroom & a deluxe. The crust is rather thin (which is great); it says the crust & sauce is homemade.
They have a 4 page menu to select from.