Antonio's Real New York Pizza

New York style pizza all the way in Colorado. The boys wanted some pizza for a night in the cabin and this place came through. Starting with a margherita, I thought this was just fine. Next, the chicken and pineapple was tasty with a good amount of both ingredients. Finally, we got the mega don cheese. All three pizzas had nice crust, not a lot of flop, weren’t too oily, and a good disbursement of toppings. This wasn’t the best pizza I’ve ever had but it was solid and did the job.

This is the best pizza place in Estes Park. We were here at about 4:00 pm on a Wednesday and had great service. After being to so many places that complain about being understaffed, it was so nice to be in a place with plenty of pleasant helpful employees. We had a thin crust pizza and another with thick crust so everyone was happy getting their favorite. Delicious! It was a fun experience to see the pizza delivered to our table by a motorized cart (kind of like having R2D2 delivery).

If you are in the area, this is a must stop. This might be some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. We ordered the Detroit style pizza. It was amazing. The right amount of cheese and sauce in every bite. We also had the salad and garlic cheese bread which were also delicious. Despite the fact that you don’t have a primary waiter for your table (everyone just helps out), the service was very friendly and we were very well taken care off. I can’t wait to go back to this place!!!

Best Pizzeria in Colorado, Fresh ingredients! Family environment.
Antonio’s is the real 516 New York style.
I got the Italian salad and the Italian Hoagie, they were both incredible, This photo is of HALF of it, nice big portions.
The staff is so welcoming, attentive and present. They look happy to be there.
Good ambiance, good music, nice big booths, could host large parties here. I wish we lived here so we could enjoy this on a regular. Thanks Antonio’s

Good sized New York slices! We ordered the “huge” size, which is every bit of the advertised 28 inches. We didn’t order a deep dish, but all of the ones we saw going out looked amazing. They have this nifty pizza robot that brings you your pizza, so that’s fun. They have this “red light green light” table tag service which wasn’t clearly explained to us, nor did it work very well. Standard table waiting service would be preferred. Other than that hiccup, good dining experience.