Wiggly Worm Bait Supply

I’m visiting family in NY and Googled “fishing gear near me” to pick up a few essentials (and maybe some things I never tried). Wiggly Worm came up so I thought I’d check it out. This place is absolutely packed with lures, plastics and tackle at great prices. I spent about an hour walking around the store looking at everything from the taxidermy fish and creatures to the live bait and tackle. Just before leaving I noticed a room in the back dedicated to plastic baits so don’t miss it! Will definitely be coming back the next time I’m up from the Carolinas.

This was the nicest experience I have had at a bait/fishing supply shop. Everyone was very friendly, knowledgeable, and informative. Kevin is wonderful and is also a guide for some interesting fishing trips. The shop is very cool inside! Lots of taxidermy, cool to see. I stopped by myself this morning and enjoyed the shop and conversation. They helped get my dads old rods fishing ready. Next time I will have to stop by with my son. Thank you!

Great quick easy stop with a knowledgeable and helpful staff. They got us set up with everything we need for a spontaneous short fishing trip easily and quickly. Great prices too. 5/5 stars.

Great local bait shop. Even more than that, it is full of great history and plenty of things to keep the young kids learning and curious. Our kids are always excited to go to Wiggly worm, the staff are freindly and the selection is vast for a small store. leave your politics at home, and stop in for a fair price and a good small town piece of fishing history.

Best fishing place ever Gary really knew what he was talking about and was a great help I’m truly happy I found this place and when ever I can will be coming back most definitely thanks Gary.